
The following is a transcription of a journal from Lyman C. Draper to the Virginia Historical Register And Literary Companion: Volume V, Number II, in April of 1852.
All Spellings and grammar are exactly as originally transcribed and were not altered.
The expedition of the Virginians against the Shawanoe Indians, in 1756, is an event of some importance and still more interest in the annals of the State. As yet, however, we have no proper and sufficiently satisfactory account of it before the'public. Neither Marshall, Burk, the Campbells, father and son, nor Howison, have given us, in their res- pective works, any particulars of this border enterprise. Reliable data were probably not at their command. It is true the expedition proved abortive, and sufficiently morti- fying to all concerned in it; yet composed as it was, with the exception of a small band of friendly Cherokees, cn- tirely of Virginia troops, conducted by one of Virginia's border heroes, it well deserves something more than a mere passing notice in any work illustrative of the history of the Old Dominion. The publication of Morton's Diary in the Virginia Historical Register, for July, 1851, has, at length, shed some little light upon it, but hardly sufficient to dispel the darkness that has hitherto concealed it from our view. Indeed, the information it gives us is so imperfect that it has even led one of our best antiquaries to inquire whether " the expedition to which this Diary refers, is the same with that styled the Sandy Creek expedition;" -a question which I have answered in the affirmative in the last number of the same work. But to complete the proof on this point, and to give a fuller account of this affair than has ever yet been submitted to the public, I shall now proceed to give an outline of this enterprise, drawn from an unpub- lished journal of the expedition, kept by Captain William Preston, one of the actors, and some other manuscript pa- pers in my possession. These ancient witnesses will serve to place this whole affair in quite a different light from the traditionary accounts of Withers, and other writers; and fully corroborate the authority of Lieut. Morton's Diary.- I ought, perhaps, to say here, that no man ever bore a fairer reputation than Captain, afterwards Colonel William Pres- ton; he distinguished himself at the battle of Whitsell's Mills, in March, IT81, at the head of a regiment of fron- tier riflemen, and died at the close of the Rerolution. His descendants are amongst the most talented and patriotic in our country. The place of rendezvous was Fort Frederick, on the western bank of New River, and probably at or near the well known locality of Ingle's Ferry. Maj. Andrew Lewis had the chief command, and under him were Captains Wil- liam Preston, Peter Hog, (such was Captain Hog's or- thography of his name, as original signatures of his prove; the name is modernized with the addition of a final e.) John Smith, Archibald Alexander, [ Robert?] Brecken- ridge, Woodson, and Overton, whose companies appear to have been already engaged in guarding the frontiers when called upon for this new service; together with the volun- teer companies of Captains Montgomery and Dunlap, and Captain Paris, at the head of a party of friendly Cherokees. In the latter part of 1755, one hundred and thirty Chero- kee warriors had come to the assistance of the Virginians ; whether all these were engaged in this enterprise does not distinctly appear, though all were ordered by Gov. Dinwid- die to join it; and Preston's Journal mentions that a de- tachment of forty was ordered out on a scouting excursion on one occasion during the expedition. Old Outacité, the Round O, and the Yellow Bird were the war leaders of the party~-the two latter having been commissioned Captains by Major Lewis. Col. David Stewart, of Augusta, accom- panied the troops on this perilous adventure, and seems to have acted as commissary. The whole force, including the friendly Cherokees, amounted to 365 men, of whom 340 went upon the campaign, while Lieut. Tyler and some 24 men remained to garrison Fort Frederick, and protect the neighboring frontier--an indispensable service, as while the men were rendezvousing for the expedition, two persons were killed by the savages on Red Creek, within a few miles of Fort Frederick. On Monday, the 9th February, 1750, Captain Preston, with his two Lieutenants, Audley Paul and David Robin- son, and twenty-five privates, left Fort Prince George, in pursuance of the orders of Major Lewis of the 4th of the same month, and marched for Fort Frederick, having under their charge a waggon load of 2000 lbs. of dried beef.- They reached the place of rendezvous on the night of Wednesday, the 11th; and it is added, " Captain Hog's company is but a little behind us." On Friday, the 13th, at noon, a general review of the troops took place by Maj. Lewis, at which, including the friendly Indians, about 340 men appeared-and among these were Captain Hog and his company. The next day Captain Dunlap, with his company of volunteers, 25 in number, arrived; and these made up the complement, Several days were requisite to procure a suficiency of horses, and to prepare packi-sad- les for them, with which to transport the provisions, am- munition, and other necessaries. During this delay, the Reverends John Craig and John Brown, pioneer Presbyte- rian clergymen in the Virginia Valley, preached twice re- spectively to the soldiery, and one of each of their efforts is, by Captain Preston, denominated a « Military Sermon." Major Lewis marched from Fort Frederick, on Wednes- day, February 18th, with the advance--and among them Capt. Hog's company; Captains Preston and Paris brought up the rear the following day. Passing the Bear Garden on the North Fork of Holsten, they proceeded on over two large mountains to Burke's Garden, where they arrived on the 24th, and where they found plenty of potatoes in the deserted plantations; it snowed that night. Thence they steered for the head of Clinch, which they reached the 26th; «that day," says Capt. Preston, "I bought a little horse of Lieut. Smith for €4, to carry me out of the Shaw- nee Towns;" and that night it rained. The next day, « a very great rain" compelled the troops to remain in camp, except a few hunters who killed three or four bears. On the 28th, the march was resumed, when passing several branches of Clinch, they at length reached the head of Sandy Creek, where they met with great trouble and fatigue, occasioned by a very heavy rain and the driving of the pack-horses down the creek, which was crossed and re-crossed twenty times that evening; the hunters that day killed three buffa- loes and some deer. On Sunday, the 29th, the troops crossed and re-crossed the creek, which proved to be very crooked, sixty-six times in the space of fifteen miles: «I passed the creek," says Capt. Preston, "sixteen times on foot; the Sabbath day was spent very disagreeably." On Monday, March 1st, they experienced " a great gust of thunder, hail and rain;" and Capt. Preston adds, " I bathed in ye river at nine o'clock;" signs of the enemy were seen, as on former occasions. On the 2d, they were put upon half allowance of beef, which was almost exhaust- ed. Their rations on the 3rd, were reduced to half a pound of four per man, and no meat, except what they could kill, and that was very scarce; no food for the horses, which occasioned many of them to stray away; a few bears were killed; nine miles were gained that day,- After a tedious search for the strayed horses, some of which could not be found, the toilsome march was resumed on the 4th, and about six miles only were gained; the addition of several branches very much increased the volume of the stream, and rendered it difficult for the foot men to wade, which they had to do sixteen times that day; the hunters had no success, and " nothing but hunger and fatigue" stared them in the face. On Friday, the 5th, fifteen miles were accomplished with painful difficulty, " the river being very deep, and often to cross, almost killed the men, and the more so as they were in the utmost extremity for want of provisions: " Capt. Preston records in his journal, " this day my €4 horse expired, and I was left on foot with a hungry belly, which increased my woe; and this was in- deed the case with almost every man in. the company:", Rained hard, all night; and "no appearance of a level country though it was wishfully looked for;" and encamp- ed near the Forks of Sandy. The troops did not move on Saturday, the 6th, till eleren o'clock, and then only to cross the South East Fork and encamp. The Cherokees proposed to make bark canoes to. carry themselves down the river, which was immediately put in practice; Major Lewis, at the same time, set men to work to make a large canoe to carry down the ammuni- tion, and. the small remains of the flour, then almost ex- hausted; ' the men murmured very much for want of pro- visions, and numbers. threatened to return home." When this was told to Maj. Lewis, he was " very much concerned, and had no other way to please them but to order a cask of butter to be divided among them, which was no more than a taste to each man: it rained very hard all that night, which still added to our misfortunes, as we had no tents, nor indeed hardly any other necessary for such a journey." The morning of Sunday, the 7th, was raining, yet the men continued to work at the canoes, and it was agreed upon by the officers, that Captains Smith, Preston, Breckeuridge, Dunlap, and Lieut. Morton, with their com- panies, and part of Montgomery's volunteers, making a total of 130 in number, with nearly all the horses, should proceed down the creek fifteen miles, and no further, in search of hunting ground, there to await the arrival of Major Lewis, with the remainder of the men, who tarried to complete the canoes. A single pound of four to each man was the only subsistence allotted to this advance de- tachment, and that to last until Major Lewis and the re- mainder of the men could overtake them. Although this party marched at 9 o'clock in the morning, yet so difficult was it to find a passage over the mountain for the horsemen, and to secure which they had to leave the creek some distance, that at sun-set they had accom- plished but about six miles, and encamped on the bank of the stream. No game was found; hunger and want in- creased. The mountains seemed very high, and no ap- pearance of a level country, which greatly discouraged the men. A great number of them resolved to break off home- ward next morning, justifying this unmilitary movement by declaring, that their daily allowance of half a pound of flour per man was insuffcient for their support, and even this inadequate supply would soon cease; that they were faint and weak, and could not travel the mountains, or wade the rivers as they had done; and, finally, that there was no game in the mountains, nor any prospect of a level country ahead. Capt. Preston proposed to kill horses for food. This they refused to do, saying it might answer if they were returning to support them home, but that it was not proper diet to sustain men encountering every hard- ship on a long march against an enemy. Captain Preston then urged them to make a further trial the next day down the river, to which they at length agreed with some reluc- tance. It rained hard that night. At 8 o'clock on the morning of Monday, the 8th of March, the movement down the creek was recommenced, and continued about three miles, where the rugged moun- tains so completely closed in upon the streams as to pre- clude a passage between them. It became necessary to bear off some distance from the creek, pursue up a branch, over a high mountain, and down another branch; here two elks were discovered, seven shots fired, but all unfortunately without effect. Now passing another high mountain, they came upon the head of a branch, down which they follow- ed some miles, where they met with some of the volun- teers who had kept nearer the stream, and had [luckily killed two elks within a mile of Sandy. Arriving there, after a tedious march of seven miles, camp was struck upon the bank of the creek, one of the elks was brought in and divided among that portion of the men associated with Captain Preston, to the no small joy of every man. " By that time," says Captain Preston, " hunger appeared in all our faces, and most of us had become weak and feeble, and had we not got that relief, I doubt not but several of the men would have died of hunger; their cries and complaints were pitiful and shocking, and the more so as the offi- cers could not afford them any help, for they were in equal want with their men." The volunteers had the good fortune to kill two buffaloes and an elk on the morning of Tuesday, the 9th, which af forded still furtherrelief, The men, however, still continued to murmur; no further advance movement was attempted, as it was thought that the limited distance of 15 miles be- low the Forks had been attained: A great number of the young men went out that day to hunt and view the coun- try; some of whom went seren or eight miles down the river and returned that night, reporting that they had climbed a very high mountain in order to survey the coun- try, and that there seemed to be several prodigious moun- tains before them, compared with which the country behind appeared level; that the creek seemed to bear to the west- ward, and no probability of being able to travel with horses beside it; and that they saw no game. This report very naturally dispirited the men more than ever; in short, they agreed almost to a man to set out on their return home next morning. Capt. Preston, with a full knowledge of this determinatien, convened the officers, and it. was con- cluded that each Captain should exert his best efforts to prevail on his men to stay until Major Lewis should arrive with the remainder of the troops. It rained very hard that night; and Capt. Preston confesses, that his mind was in a very confused and perplexed state to think of the men. returning in such a manner, " which would infallibly ruin the expedition." Atthough. the men, on the morning of the 10th, were pre- pared to commence their return, yet an appeal from Capt. Preston to his company, that should they go before Major Lewis' arrival, his own character would suffer by it, induced them, as well as the other companies, to stay, until a letter could be sent to the Major. Lieut. Morton was immediate- ly despatched, with two men, with a letter, wherein Capt. Preston set forth the confusion and disorder prevailing among the men, and their determination to return home; that the meat was consumed, and that nothing remained on which the men could subsist, and earnestly begged Maj. Lewis to come down that evening or next morning, if pos- sible. During the afternoon McNutt and another person arrived from the camp in the Forks with intelligence that the canoes were to set off that morning, that a horse had been killed to support the men, who were almost perished with hunger, and very uneasy. Notwithstanding the promises of the men to remain un- til the Major's arrival, they were bent on marching home- wards on Thursday morning, the 11th; but after many ar- guments and persuasions by Capi. Preston, they consented to remain that day for the Major's coming, as also for An- drew Lynam, who had been out three days making what observations he could. A little venison was procured for the support of the men that day. About noon two Indians came down in a canoe from Major Lewis' camp, reporting that the upper companies would be down that night. In the afternoon Andrew Lynam and William Hall returned with the information, that they had been fifteen miles down the stream; saw a large buffalo path, and fresh signs of buffaloes and elks; that they saw great numbers of turkies, and were of opinion that game was plenty; that they found an old fort which they believed was a hunting fort built by the Indians; that they thought the main mountain was not more than two miles beyond the farthest point to which they penetrated, but did not wait to make further discove- ries, as they judged these would be sufficient to encourage the men to prosecute their journey. While this report greatly pleased and cheered the officers, it rather increased than quieted the mutiny among the men; for they looked upon it as formed only to draw them still farther from home; that were the game ever so plenty, they said it was utterly impossible to support 340 men by it, as there was nothing else to depend on; and if they proceeded any far- ther, they must inevitably perish with hunger, which they looked upon to be more inglorions than to return and be yet serviceable to their country, when properly provided for. " These and many other weighty arguments," says Captain Preston, "they made use of, but through the whole they laid great part of our misfortunes on the com- -es for not providing necessaries for such a number of men, as we had not above fifteen days provisions when we left Fort Frederick, to support us on a journey of near 300 miles, as we suppose." Lieut. Morton returned, and informed Captain Preston that he had delivered his letter to Major Lewis, who could hardly credit the contents, and said that he had often seen the like mutiny among soldiers, and it might easily be settled, &c. Eight of Capt. Smith's men went off, and two others with them. It rained very much all night. The next morning, Friday, the 12th, Capt. Preston des- patched Lieut. Paul to meet Major Lewis, and hasten him on. The soldiers being in readiness to march up the creek, eight or ten of Capt. Preston's men had their bundles on their backs and were about to start with them; Capt. Preston reasoned with them some time to no purpose, and was finally obliged to disarm them, and take their blankets by force. Half an hour afterwards five of them were found to have gone off privately; Lieut. Robinson and one soldier were sent in pursuit, and soon overtook and brought the deserters back to camp. Capt. Woodson now arrived with some of his company, with the intelligence, that his canoe overset, and he had lost his tents, and every thing valuable in it; that Major Lewis' canoe was sunk in the river, and that the Major, Capt. Overton, Lieut. Gun, and one other man had to swim for their lives, and that several things of value were lost, particularly five or six fine guns. Major Lewis and two others soon after made their appearance, and gave information that being shipwrecked was the cause of so long detaining the Major, who left Capt Hog with his company to bring down the canoes and baggage, for which latter horses would hare to be sent. The party of ten men who left the day before for home, were met by Major Lewis, and pre- tended that they went with the consent of their offcers, who would have gone with them but for fear of their supe- riors. One of the men who came with Major Lewis brought in a little bear, which he took to Capt. Preston's tent, where the Major lodged that night; « by which," says Preston, "I had a good supper and breakfast- a rarity." On Saturday morning, the 13th of March, Major Lewis gave orders to each Captain to call his company together immediately, which was done, when the Major told the soldiers that he was informed of their design to go home, and that he was much surprised at it; he hoped they would alter their intentions of mutiny and desertion, and pursue the journey. He also set forth the ill-consequences that would certainly attend such conduct; he felt confident that they would be well supported when they reached the hunting ground, which he thought must be very near, and horses would support them for sometime. Notwithstand- ing all that could be said, the men appeared obstinately bent on going home; for, they said, if they went forward they must perish or eat horses, neither of which they were willing to do, Then Major Lewis stepped off some yards, and desired all who were willing to serve their country and share his fate, to go with him. All the offcers, and some of the privates, not above twenty or thirty, joined him; up- on which Montgomery's volunteers marched off, and were immediately followed by Capt. Preston's company, except the Captain, his two Lieutenants, and four privates; Cap- tain Smith's company also followed these bad examples, - Captain Woodson kept his company together all day under a pretence of marching down the country against the Shawanoes some other way, which was only to drew one day's provision for them-_for a buffalo had been killed. Major Lewis spoke to old Outacité, who appeared much grieved to see the men desert in such a manner, and said he was willing to proceed; but some of the warriors and young men were yet behind, and he was doubtful of them, but would send off a messenger to them to bring them down-which he did. The old chief added, that the white men could not bear abstinence like the Indians who would not complajn of hunger. Capt. Paris and Colonel Stewart came to the camp that morning with the information that one of Capt. Brecken- ridge's men got drowned the evening before, in attempting to cross the stream for some meal. Indeed," says Pres- ton's Journal, " hunger and want were so much increased that any man in the camp would have ventured his life for a supper. A small quantity of wet meal was brought in ; I saw about one pound given to twelve men, and one of them bought a share for which he gave two shillings. One Jesse Mayo offered thirteen days hire as a pack-horseman for two pounds of bear's meat; so that it is impossible to ex- press the abject condition we were in, both before and after the men deserted us, except when a little fresh meat was procured, which would not last any time, nor had it any strength to support men, as the salt was all lost. Lieut. Paul was ordered off with a party of men to Capt. Hog to bring the baggage, and on his way killed a buffalo. Mr. Dunlap's volunteers went off in the afternoon." Here abruptly ends Capt. Preston's Journal. There can be no doubt, though Capt. Preston, Lieutenants Paul and Robinson, Old Outacité, and a patriotic few, resolved to share Maj. Lewis' uncertain fortunes, that all hope of ac- complishing any thing at all adequate to the great sacrifi- ces they would necessarily have to make, with so diminish- ed a force, was now deemed utterly impracticable; and that to adrance further would be but a reckless waste of life and energies; and, consequently, the further prosecu- tion of the expedition was reluctantly abandoned, and all made the best of their way home. They must hare been well nigh two weeks in reaching the settlements, as Sparks mentions their being " six weeks in the woods,' and Wash- ington speaks of their return, under date Winchester, the 7th of April. We can only conjecture their sufferings on their homeward march; that horses were very likely killed for food, buffalo tugs devoured, and shot-pouch flaps eaten, to satisfy in part the cravings of long-protracted hunger. With what inexpressible joy must these half-famished men have beheld the first inhabited cabins upon the out-skirts of the settlements ! It is difficult-even with our new light on the subject- to ascertain the precise object or design of this ill-starred expedition. Taylor and Withers affirm that it was the de- struction of the Roanoke settlement. From the com- mencement of hostilities to the period of the marching of Major Lewis's little army, seventy persons had been killed, wounded, or captured on Holston, New, and Greenbrier rivers, while but a single individual was disturbed on the Roanoke, and he taken prisoner. This fact is derived from a manuscript account kept at the time by Capt. William Preston. But I have yet no certain means of determining the particular destination of the troops. Taylor and With- ers say the plan was to attack the Scioto Shawanee towns, and to establish a fort and garrison at the mouth of Big Sandy. A manuscript letter before me of Gov. Dinwiddie, dated Williamsburg, Dec. 15th, 1755, addressed to Capts. Preston and Smith, mentions that they are to march to the attack of the Shawanesse towns; and Capt. Preston speaks in his Journal of the design to go " to the Shawne Towns." Washington's Letters indicate « the Shawanese Town" as the point of attack, and Mr. Sparks says that it was situa- ted at the mouth of the great Kenawha. To be a little more precise, its locality was on the Southern bank of the Ohio, just above Old Town Creek, three miles above Point Pleasant, and was known as the Upper Shawanoe Town at the mouth of the Scioto. Inasmuch as the mouth of Sandy, where Lewis designed to strike the Ohio, was about mid- way between these two important Shawanoe Settlements, it would appear probable that either or both were intended objects of attack, as circumstances might favor. Major Lewis in a letter to Capt. Preston now before me, dated Jan. 28th, 1756, says, he has received his "instructions from his Honor; they are not particular; he has left almost every thing to my management." It is impossible as yet to be more particular on this point. The faithfulness of the noble old Cherokee Chief, when timidity and desertion swayed the minds of so many, very naturally inspires a wish to know something more concern- ing him. With some pains I have brought together, from various sources, the following sketch: OUTACITE, OR THE MAN-KILLER, was among the most noted Cherokee chiefs of his day. The name he bore was the highest honorary title among the Cherokees, conferred as the reward of uncommon valor. As early as 1721, he was known as King of the Lower and Middle Cherokee settlements, and treated with Gov. Nicholson, of South Carolina; and in 1730, he was one of the Cherokee em- bassy, who visited England under the superintendence of Sir Alexander Cumming, and made a treaty with King George II. In 1755-'56, we find him in the service of the Colonies on the Virginia frontiers, serving patiently on Lewis' disastrous Shawanoe Expedition, and probably par- ticipating in the defeat of Donville's party; and, in 1757, he joined Col. Washington at the head of twenty-seven warriors. What part he took, if any, in the Cherokee out- break of 1758, we are ignorant ; he was, however, one of the signers of the short-lived treaty of peace with Gor. Lyttleton, in Dec. 1759. From about this period he is gen- erally mentioned as Outacité, or the Judd's Friend, in con- sequence of having saved, from the fury of his countrymen, a white man of the name of Judd, who was probably a tra- der. It was a richly deserved commemoration of a gene- rous deed. When, in 1760, the Cherokees succeeded in obtaining the surrender of Fort Loudon, in the Cherokee country, and treacherously fell upon Capt. Demeré and his fellow prisoners, Outacité made powerful exertions for the salva- tion of the whites, and but for his unwearied efforts none would probably have escaped the massacre. "He went around the field," say the newspaper accounts of the time, " ordering and calling to the Indians to desist, and the representations he made to them stopped the further pro- gress and effects of their barbarous and brutal rage. He declares it as his opinion and resolution, that if they can now obtain peace, "there never shall be more war as long as the old warriors live.' » Out of about two hundred cap- tives, Capt. Demeré and twenty-five others were inhumanly slaughtered--the large proportion saved, is a lasting com- mentary on Outacité's noble promptings of humanity at a time when all others seemed completely under the infu- ence of the demon of blood. In 1764-'65, we find him at the head of a party of Chero- kees making a foray to the Mississippi, where he intercep- ted two French batteaux ascending the river, loaded with amunition designed for the Shawanoes, and with them cap- tured two French emissaries. He was a signer of the treaty of Lochabar, near Ninety-Six, in South Carolina, in Oct. 1770; in July, 1'777, his name figures at the treaty of the Long Island of Holston, and, as we hear no more of him, he probably died soon after. He must, at this period, hare been fully eighty years of age; and no Cherokee chieftain, except Attacullaculla or the Little Carpenter, has left behind him a more deservedly distinguished name. Of the RoUND O, and YELLOW BIRD, who also accom- panied Maj. Lewis on the Shawanoe Expedition, little is known- the former is said, in the newspapers of that day, to have died among his people of small pox, early in 1760; and a Cherokee chief bearing the name of the latter, sign- ed the treaty of Hopewell in 1786, and that of Holston, in 1791. Lyman C. Draper






